« Planned Parenthood Aurora clinic will open today! | Main | Nicaragua abortion ban is killing women »
October 3, 2007
Quick Hit: NY Times on Verizon censorship
The New York Times has a great editorial today, taking apart the ridiculousness was Verizon's refusal to run NARAL text messages.
A snippet:
Leave aside for the moment the sorry spectacle of a major American company aiming to make campaigns even more substance-free than they already are. The Verizon policy was textbook censorship. Any government that tried it would be rightly labeled authoritarian. The First Amendment prohibits the United States government from anything approaching that sort of restriction.
Make sure to read the whole thing.
Posted by Jessica at October 3, 2007 11:28 AM
Comments
The New York Times is no friend of any speech except its own. Despite its complaint about "authoritarianism," it supported the government's right to censor ads by Wisconsin Right to Life under McCain Feingold. Why it's more upset about a private company engaging in censorship, I can't fathom. I don't like what Verizon did either, and am glad it reversed its policy, but the Times editorial was sheer hypocrisy.
It is also noteworthy that Verizon was not discriminating against the pro-choice side as many have insinuated. It was simply trying to keep what it considered the "unsavory" topic of abortion off its network, much like a supermarket bulletin board might tear down such messages for fear of offending customers. Again, I don't think it was justified in the context of text messaging -- but note that Planned Parenthood itself found the word "abortion" so unsavory that it omitted that term from the press release defending its opening of the Aurora clinic.
Posted by: RavingAtheist at October 3, 2007 5:36 PM
